Recommendations for Writing Comments on Student …
Recommendations for Writing Comments on Student Papers ..
If, for example, you write, "I cannot understand where you are going here," or "I cannot find the direction of the paper," or "My difficulty here is the lack of a clear central point," the student should understand that his or her job has not been done, and yet should not feel under attack.
The Landing: Grading comments for essays on literature
In regard to that evidence, keep one suggestion in mind as you continue to write for academic contexts. Wherever possible, provide specific details and examples, leaving your reader with an image that supports your claims. This specificity would strengthen your second paragraph in particular. Your background as a student in two different schools is clearly relevant and gives you authority to comment on class-based differences in teaching styles. Rather than general statements about these differences, however, consider how a specific illustration or two would lend stronger support to your claim. You might, for example, recall a specific assignment in one school compared to a same-subject assignment in the other school.
Essay feedback comments to students - …
I did not find Le Moult' s essay "short and sweet" as you did. I found it detailed and complex. I found his strategy for presenting his ideas sophisticated. He asked me as his reader to bring a lot of what I know about the world to his argument. Perhaps you and I found the argument so different because we have had different life experiences. Let me illustrate what I mean by offering you my reading [italicized and in brackets ] of the paragraph in Le Moult's essay from which you drew information for your essay.
Rubric Worksheet for an Essay (doc) ..
I turned with interest to reading John Le Moult's "Legalize Drugs" after reading your first draft of "What If Drugs Were Legal?" I read Le Moult' s essay four times. I wanted to follow his argument carefully, first, because you reacted to it so strongly as to almost dismiss it out-of-hand ("My only and most important argument to Le Moult is the physical harm it would bring by legalizing drugs."), and second, because Le Moult himself introduced his argument by wondering if it possible, rationally, to consider legalizing drugs ("Perhaps it is time to think the unthinkable.").